The IT industry utilizes capture-the-flag (CTF) competitions to assess, evaluate and train employees or potential hires. This construct has proven valuable by providing outreach to previously untouched populations, a quantitative measure of an individual's capabilities, and a catalyst for training. But tactics taught by "pen test puppy mills" such as aggressive scans of entire subnets followed by automated attacks are no longer acceptable. We have developed a new construct to CTFs and provide tools to assist implementers. We propose that CTFs should reward finesse and an in-depth understanding of underlying technologies while brutally punishing haphazard practices. Our construct outlines how the competition should react to the participant by introducing categories of mitigation, detection, attribution, and retribution. Participants will find themselves being assessed on their check-collect-clean procedures as well as their ability to gain access. With theses dimensions, competitors will find exponential benefits for good practices and encourage the development of innovative techniques. As a result, the penetration testing industry will raise the quality of work to better reflect the more advanced threats. As an additional benefit, blue team components will assess their skills against the most dangerous threats out there.