How to Be Wrong Faster: Testing Assumptions During Incident Response

No ratings

Presented at BSides Atlanta 2026 by

During an incident, teams are rarely short on information. They are short on a shared way to distinguish what they have observed from what they merely suspect. Alerts, dashboards, chat messages, and expert opinions arrive at different speeds, allowing a plausible explanation to harden into “the cause” before the team has tested it. This talk examines how premature certainty shapes incident response and introduces a lightweight incident reasoning exercise for making assumptions easier to see and revise. Through a short, evolving scenario, attendees will explore how to separate observation from interpretation, preserve competing explanations, surface contradictory evidence, and identify which unknowns matter most to the next decision. The exercise is designed to work without new software and can be adapted for tabletop exercises, incident reviews, or live response. It does not attempt to tell responders what decision to make. Instead, it gives teams a shared structure for examining how they reached their current understanding and what evidence would cause them to revise it. Attendees will leave with practical prompts and a reusable exercise they can test with their own teams.